The Capital Gains Conundrum

With proposals to eliminate the capital gains tax for people earning over $400,000 a year, it leaves us with a conundrum. Should we deliberately be taking long-term capital gains at this point in time?

Taxes are easy to manage, yet difficult to avoid. Typically strategies involve some combination of rescheduling strategies, such as: Roth conversions, tax-loss harvesting, holding onto gains so they’re long-term, deferring gains indefinitely, qualified charitable distributions from an IRA, donor advised funds, charitable remainder trusts, and even more advanced strategies such as GRATs, trusts, investing in opportunity zones. And of course rebalancing at the household level instead of the account level can reduce turnover and reduce taxes. But in most of these examples we’re managing taxes, not avoiding them. In some cases we are mitigating. The challenge is we’ve got new tax hikes on the table, and are they significant enough for us to throw some of this out the window and just take capital gains tax at 23% today for fear of a much higher marginal income tax bracket being used in the future

There’s a lot of money in selling fear. Be they blogs, 24-hour news – you name it. So the challenge is with the potential for capital gains tax hikes, or worse yet, the elimination of the capital gains tax and replacement of ordinary income tax, do we go ahead and accelerate the realization of long-term capital gains?

The challenge I see is there’s not enough political capital in Congress or the Senate – it’s too closely split to get a bill through that includes the elimination of capital gains tax, which probably explains why we hear less and less of that specific provision than we have recently. In fact, the Democrats are running into trouble right now with their own party up in New York and California, trying to eliminate the SALT caps. Which that’s the sales and local income tax, which probably every economist thought was a good law back in 2017 and every high-tax state misses significantly. Because what was it? It was a federal subsidy for high local taxes.

I’m very wary on the flip side of letting gains just run forever to avoid taxes. The problem with that strategy is if you have a growth strategy and leave it alone long enough, you’re now actually quite aggressive, especially after the last few months. So we would hate to see you actually lose more in investment portfolio value than you would have paid in taxes if you capture those gains in the course of normal rebalancing. So active tax strategies, like the ones we listed earlier, yes, including household rebalancing and judiciously capturing long-term capital gains. But deliberately realizing gains for fear of the future? No, that future is still a little far out. One of my favorite quotes is “Be careful. Don’t let the tax tail wag the dog.” We wish you the best of investing success.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Email

Send Us a Message

A-Players With Intent

Additional Reading Suggestions

  • How to be a Power Connector: The 5+50+100 Rule for Turning Your Business Network into Profits By: Judy Robinett. For sale on Amazon here 
  • Never Eat Alone, Expanded and Updated: And Other Secrets to Success, One Relationship at a Time By: Keith Ferrazzi. For sale on Amazon here 
  • The Fine Art of Small Talk: How To Start a Conversation, Keep It Going, Build Networking Skills – – and Leave a Positive Impression! By: Debra Fine. For sale on Amazon here
  • Book Yourself Solid: The Fastest, Easiest, and Most Reliable System for Getting More Clients Than You Can Handle Even if You Hate Marketing and Selling By: Michael Port. For sale on Amazon here 
  • The Art of Selling to the Affluent: How to Attract, Service, and Retain Wealthy Customers and Clients for Life By: Matt Oechsli. For sale on Amazon here 
  • Business Class: Etiquette Essentials for Success at Work By: Jacqueline Whitmore. For sale on Amazon here 
  • The Drunkard’s Walk: How Randomness Rules Our Lives By: Leonard Mlodinow. For sale on Amazon here
  • Superforecasting: The Art and Science of Prediction By: Philip E. Tetlock and Dan Gardner. For sale on Amazon here
  • Turn the Ship Around!: A True Story of Turning Followers into Leaders By: L. David Marquet. For sale on Amazon here
  • Leaders Eat Last: Why Some Teams Pull Together and Others Don’t By: Simon Sinek. For sale on Amazon here
  • Triggers By: Marshall Goldsmith. For sale on Amazon here
  • Successful Women Speak Differently: 9 Habits That Build Confidence, Courage, and Influence By: Valorie Burton. For sale on Amazon here